Homeopathy

topic posted Wed, May 11, 2005 - 6:38 AM by  Unsubscribed
I didn't understand Homeopathy until I found this parody of it.

www.gulligo.com
posted by:
Unsubscribed
  • Re: Homeopathy

    Wed, May 11, 2005 - 6:59 AM
    There's a lot of similarity between homeopathy and vaccination.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Homeopathy

      Wed, May 11, 2005 - 7:12 AM
      None whatsoever. Vaccinations like the one that stopped polio were developed by folks who did real tests that had real results and saved millions of people. Homeopathy is based on the totally disproven idea that water has "memory". If someone wishes to use a homeopathic solution that is fine by me. I would advise them to see a real doctor if their condidtion is serious.
      Unlike vaccinations, homeopathic solutions are not monitored for safety. So called alternative medicine (alternative to medicine?) should be regulated for the same reasons that Rx meds are regulated.
      • Re: Homeopathy

        Wed, May 11, 2005 - 7:27 AM
        Fair enough. None of what you say was among the similarities I was referring to.

        I did not mean that they were literally similar, only that they both depend on a principle of similarity.

        Your point is well taken, though I disagree with the "whatsoever" part--absolutes are negated by as little as one instance to the contrary.
        • Unsu...
           

          Re: Homeopathy

          Wed, May 11, 2005 - 9:52 AM
          the term 'alternative medicine' implies a fairly wide swath of protocols, some traditional, some even ancient, some freaky (woo-woo) and some completely asinine - would you write them all off with the same penstroke?

          P.S. the guilligo advert is choice -
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: Homeopathy

            Wed, May 11, 2005 - 10:10 AM
            Would not write any thing off. They should undergo the same standard double blind kind of tests that modern medicines undergo. A few years ago ecanasia was the flavor of the month. Tests have shown that the claims made for it were very overststed.
            • Re: Homeopathy

              Wed, June 1, 2005 - 11:07 AM
              Echinacea as the flavor of the month was & is marketed in its gross & common form as an Herb. Echinacea can be acquired as a Homeopathic preparation but is rarely used by the average person or even knowledgeable Health store shopper as such unless they happen to get it in a complex that is marketed at a disease similiar to otc allopathic marketing ie cold medicine.

              Tests have shown that not all marketed products contain the amounts of active stated ingrediants & that labelling is usually inadequate for successful use due to FDA inhibiting proper labelling allowances & a consumers lack of knowledge & understanding of the product.

              Herbalogy is not Homeopathy, or Naturopathy or Supplementation or Nutrition.....

              There seems to be a trend even among people who think of themselves as Aternative Healthy people to misuse, hence abuse, terms of health treatments.

              Herbalogy is the study & science of Herbs as used in Healthcare Traditionally & around the World for 1000s of years.

              Homeopathics (see myother post if you care to) is the study & treatment of Similiars, using a minute molecular structure of a substance to incite a system to balance & cure illness.

              Naturopathy is an umbrella term for studying & using treatments that fall under the Traditional & Natural (usually) methods similiar to the term Holistic which is different in the parameters of treatments of using multiple perspectives & modalities.
      • Re: Homeopathy

        Wed, June 1, 2005 - 10:51 AM
        Hello. I had to jump in here without being familiar with the Tribe members but........
        The 'father of vacinations', whom I do not remember his name at the moment but could look it up, has attributed his findings to the research done by Dr Hahnemann the Father of Homeopathy
        (his 250th birthday was noted & celebrated this spring).

        The differences are that the Vaccination Theory took the concept of Homeopathy Similiars - that Like treats Like (rather traditional & bibical), & tried using a gross (as in large) 'live' virus to create antibodies within the system to prevent or repel Like, i.e. a disease, & Homeopathic Similiars use molecular levels of non live substances to incite the system to create an immune response to heal the system.

        Homeopathy preseded Vaccination Theory by about a 100 years (again do not remember exactly at the moment). It still took a long time to create the medicine of Vaccinations as we know it while Homeopathy has been used successfully by a majority of 1st World medically sophisticated countries for over 200 yrs including the ruling governmental familys. The #1 cold/flu medicine in the whole of France, allopathic or traditional, is a homeopathic - Occillisium, a dead virus from duck liver.

        In our country their are Allopathic Drs versed in Homeopathy that have attempted to perscribe & create Homeopathics for people with AIDS & other Chronic life threatening immune diseases by using their own blood as a source of antibodies & or tissue but out Government have disuaded this bcz only they & theirs can come up with a 'Cure' for such possibly chronic costly profits from disease rather than a singular individualized one. The FDA has also seen fit inder this possibility concept to inhibit the release/sale of future Gland & Organ homeopathics that the companies have offered to practitoners in the past though it is not illegal in anyway.

        So Bear on the contrary, Homeopathics for 200 years & millions of people, are much more monitored than allopathic Rx meds in that they are individualized to each bodys response to a disease & if not the proper substance than the substance is inert where Allopathic Rx Meds, with less than a 100 years, ok maybe 10 or 20 yrs testing at best, are strong synthesized substances that will affect the body whether it is correct for the illness or not & only tested in theory until reaching the masses where the feedback real test begins for side effects & damage to the individual.

        Where you got yr fantasy notoin of Homeopathy is based on "water has memory" I cannot conceive. Have You read Dr. Hanemanns research? Any Homeopathic research tracts or history? & your personal training in Traditional medicines? Training in Allopathic medicines? Studies: Biochemistry, Anatomy, physiology, biology???

        And I assure you if a Homeopathist Dr or any competant Alternative Practioner (as I think you think they should be called)
        thought a person had a 'serious' illness that sould be seen by an Allopathic Dr then they would without hesitance say so, & be pleased to work with & in conjunction with them.

Recent topics in "I Don't Understand It!"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
I don't understand other people... darlene 1 April 3, 2007
Why aren't we in total revolt? decimus 18 August 17, 2005
dumb-ass car names decimus 6 July 16, 2005
Dark Tunnel Jøøls 13 July 2, 2005